How To Choose Cybersecurity Awareness Training For Your Employees: A Guide For New Jersey Businesses

Your employees finish their training courses. The dashboard shows green checkmarks. But when someone gets an unusual payment request or an unexpected login prompt, would they know what to do?
That’s the question security awareness training for employees needs to answer. Course completion tells you who took part. It doesn’t tell you whether your team can spot a threat, verify a request, or get help quickly.
For New Jersey businesses choosing their first program or reviewing their current IT provider, the decision goes beyond the training software. You also need to know who runs the program, follows up on gaps, and responds when an employee raises a concern.
Here’s how to compare your options.
Choose Lessons That Match Your Team’s Daily Decisions
A course library can look good without covering the situations your staff face. Start by asking what employees should do differently after each lesson.
Useful topics include spotting phishing, protecting passwords, handling sensitive files, and checking requests for money or account access. Look for lessons on social engineering: attempts to trick someone into sharing data or taking an unsafe action.
Then ask how the provider adapts those lessons to different roles. For example:
- A New Jersey construction office might need practice checking a subcontractor’s request to change bank details.
- A manufacturing purchasing team might need to question an unexpected supplier document or delivery notice.
- A healthcare office might need guidance on checking a request for patient records before sharing them.
These are examples of how role-based training can make a lesson useful. Everyone needs the basics, while staff who handle payments, records, or admin access need extra guidance for those tasks.
Ask to review a sample lesson. Does it explain the safer next step in plain language? Can staff apply it without needing to become IT experts?
Look For Training Your Whole Team Can Use
An office employee and a field supervisor may have very different access to a computer during the day. A program should account for both.
Check whether lessons work on the devices staff use, offer captions or needed language options, and fit around shifts, site visits, and customer appointments. Short lessons, often called microlearning, can make it easier to cover one decision at a time.
Ask about ongoing reminders and reinforcement. That might include brief refreshers, new examples, and extra coaching when a topic causes confusion. Also confirm when new hires get training and how lessons change when someone takes on new tasks.
There isn’t one schedule that fits every business. You need a plan your team can follow and someone in charge of keeping it up to date.
If you’re unsure which risks deserve attention first, a cybersecurity risk assessment can identify gaps that should shape your training priorities.
Evaluate Phishing Simulations And The Follow-Up
Phishing simulations send controlled test messages to see how staff respond. When comparing providers, ask about the scenarios they use and what happens after each exercise.
Do the tests reflect the messages your staff get? Do they cover business email compromise, such as someone posing as an executive or vendor to request money? Will employees learn how to verify the request and report it?
Ask the provider to explain its approach to feedback. Staff who miss a warning sign need a useful explanation and a chance to practice. Choose a program that uses results for coaching and encourages people to speak up about mistakes.
Results also need context. The NIST Phish Scale helps training teams rate how hard a phishing email is for a person to spot. That helps them explain test results beyond the click rate.
An easier test can produce fewer clicks without showing that staff learned more. Ask how the provider accounts for test difficulty when reporting progress.

Check What Happens When Someone Reports A Threat
Training should teach staff where to get help, including when they’ve already clicked a link or shared data.
Before choosing a program, ask the provider to walk through this situation: an employee gets a suspicious message, isn’t sure whether it’s safe, and reports it.
Who gets the report? Who checks the message? How does the employee learn whether they can proceed? If the concern arrives outside normal support hours, what should they do?
A suspicious message reporting button can make reporting easier, but the next steps need an owner. Staff also need a way to raise concerns from mobile devices or when they can’t access email.
Reporting needs to lead to help. Connect this process to your email security support. Training helps staff recognize concerns, while email protection and threat checks help address suspicious messages. Monmouth Cyber’s email security services connect employee reports with checks and guidance on next steps.
Confirm the support hours and response arrangements in the service plan.
Ask Who Will Manage The Program
A training platform still needs someone to enroll users, assign lessons, schedule exercises, review results, and follow up. If those tasks fall to an already busy office manager, they can become another set of unfinished tasks.
When comparing managed security awareness training providers, request a written list of responsibilities. It should cover:
- Adding new employees and removing people who leave.
- Choosing lessons and running phishing simulations.
- Sending reminders and handling missed training.
- Giving coaching for repeated gaps.
- Reviewing reported threats and sharing results with leadership.
Your business may still need to approve policies, provide staff updates, and set aside training time. The provider should explain what it handles and what it needs from you.
Review pricing against that scope. A software license and a managed program can leave you with very different amounts of admin work. Check whether setup, reporting tools, coaching, and review meetings are included.
Measure More Than Course Completion
Ask to see a sample report before you sign up. It should help you see what staff are learning and what needs attention.
Useful security awareness training metrics include:
| Metric | What To Look For |
|---|---|
| Training completion | Whether everyone assigned training took part, including new hires. |
| Knowledge retention | Whether later checks show that staff remember key lessons. |
| Phishing click rate | How often people click links in test messages, viewed alongside test difficulty. |
| Reporting rate | How often staff flag simulated threats. |
| Time to report | How quickly staff raise a concern after receiving a test message. |
| Recurring gaps | Which topics or behaviors need more coaching. |
Ask who reviews these findings and suggests the next step. A report should lead to a decision, such as revisiting payment checks or making the reporting process easier to use.
No single score proves your business is safe. Look for trends across tests of similar difficulty, along with follow-up that addresses what the results show.
Start Comparing Programs By Support And Follow-Through
Stop using completed courses as your main test of value. Start asking each provider to show how lessons, reporting, support, and improvement fit together.
Use these questions to narrow your shortlist:
- Can you show us lessons suited to our employees’ roles?
- How will office, remote, and field users take part?
- What happens after someone misses a simulated threat?
- Who responds when an employee reports a suspicious message?
- Which tasks will our team still need to manage?
- How will you explain progress and suggest changes?
If you already have an IT provider, use the same questions at your next service review. Ask for examples from your current program so you can judge what you’re receiving.
What Better Support Could Look Like
You don’t need a dedicated training department to ask for this level of support.
Consider this hypothetical example: a New Jersey contractor has about 45 computers and staff split between its office and job sites. Leadership gets completion reports but doesn’t know who checks suspicious emails.
A more useful plan would assign that responsibility, give staff a reporting route they can use, and include lessons on supplier payment requests. Reviews would examine reporting behavior and decide where more coaching is needed.
That gives the owner a way to evaluate the program and discuss gaps with the provider, without having to chase every training assignment.
Choose A Cybersecurity Partner Who Can Support Your Team
Monmouth Cyber provides security awareness training as part of its broader cybersecurity offering for New Jersey businesses. Our services also include email protection and incident response support, connecting employee awareness with technical help.
If you’re unsure what your current program delivers, Book A Free Consultation to discuss your training arrangements, responsibilities, and cybersecurity needs.
Ready to give your employees useful training backed by cybersecurity support? Explore Managed Cybersecurity Services for New Jersey Businesses.
About The Author